CULTURE · KNOWLEDGE LIBRARY · 08
Western Tarot
29 min read · 10 sections
Tarot is the West’s best-known divination system — and, unlike Bazi or LiuYao, it reads the present state rather than a lifelong structure.
8.0Opening: an origin that must be corrected first
Search online for where tarot comes from and the claim you meet most often is this:
“Tarot began in ancient Egypt. It is a surviving fragment of the Book of Thoth, carried into Europe by the Gypsies…”
This claim is false.
Where it actually comes from is a public guess made by a French clergyman in 1781 — a guess with no basis in any historical source, copied and recopied for the next two hundred years until it turned into “common knowledge”.
Three claims that have been disproved:
| Popular claim | The reality |
|---|---|
| Tarot comes from the Egyptian Book of Thoth | A speculation of 1781 by Court de Gébelin. There is no record of tarot anywhere in Egyptian sources, and Egyptologists had already disproved the idea in the 19th century |
| The Gypsies brought tarot to Europe from India | The Roma (the Gypsies) reached western Europe in the 15th century, close in time to tarot's first appearance, but there is no evidence at all that the two were connected |
| Tarot is a secret tradition of Jewish Kabbalah | Tarot was joined to Kabbalah only after Eliphas Lévi, in the 19th century. The tarot cards of the 15th century carry no Kabbalistic symbols whatsoever |
The real origin, supported by documents and surviving cards:
Tarot began as a card game played in northern Italy in the 15th century, called Tarocchi. The earliest surviving cards are the Visconti-Sforza deck, painted by hand for the ducal family of Milan around 1440–1450 — a luxury object, not a tool of divination.
In other words: for about 250 years tarot was purely a game. Its use for divination dates only from the end of the 18th century, and its occult system from the 19th.
Why this correction matters: a great deal of Chinese-language tarot writing still repeats the “Egyptian origin” story, which leaves the whole body of knowledge standing on a false foundation. Getting this straight is where this library's professionalism shows.
8.1What tarot is
8.1.1The basic structure: 78 cards
A standard tarot deck has 78 cards, in two parts:
| Part | Number | Composition |
|---|---|---|
| Major Arcana | 22 | Numbered 0–21, from The Fool to The World |
| Minor Arcana | 56 | 4 suits × 14 cards (Ace–10 plus 4 court cards) |
How tarot compares with other card systems:
| System | Cards | Structure | Uses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tarot | 78 | 22 Major + 56 Minor | Divination, self-exploration |
| Playing cards | 52 | 4 suits × 13 | Games (tarot is a distant cousin of playing cards; both descend from old Italian and Islamic cards) |
| Lenormand cards | 36 | No suits | Divination (they appeared at the end of the 18th century, later than tarot) |
| Oracle cards | Varies | Freely designed | Inspiration, meditation (a 20th-century invention) |
8.1.2The fundamental difference between tarot and Eastern destiny arts
This is the most important section in the chapter. Only once the difference is clear does tarot's place become clear.
| Dimension | Bazi / LiuYao | Tarot |
|---|---|---|
| Theoretical basis | Yin-Yang and the Five Elements, the Heavenly Stems and Earthly Branches | Western element theory, number symbolism, image archetypes |
| View of time | Cyclical time (the stem-branch cycle, Major Luck and Annual Fortune) | The present moment (the state of “right now”) |
| Input needed | Requires a birth time or the time the hexagram was cast | Requires no personal information at all — only a question and a draw |
| Method | A fixed algorithm (casting the chart, setting up the hexagram) | No fixed algorithm; it works through association with images and interpretation |
| What it describes | Structure (the pattern of a whole life) | State (the present situation and its tendency) |
| Repeatability | The same person at the same time always casts the same chart | The same question drawn at different times gives different cards |
| Core mechanism | Analogical inference (time as structure) | Synchronicity (Jung) and projection (psychology) |
The difference in one sentence:
The Eastern system is a coordinate grid for time — it places the moment you were born inside a cyclical system and locates it there
Western tarot is a mirror held up to the present — it uses randomly drawn images to show you your current inner state
8.1.3What tarot does not “predict”
The classic tarot position (a point of consensus in mainstream tarot literature):
Tarot shows possibilities that grow out of the present state, not a future already fixed. If the person involved makes different choices, the outcome changes — and that is precisely where tarot's practical use lies.
This position gives far more weight to personal agency than the destiny arts do, and it is why tarot is easier to accept in the context of modern psychology.
8.2From Italian playing cards to occult tool
8.2.1Stage one · The age of the game deck (15th century – early 18th century)
Key facts:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| c. 1370s | Cards reach Europe from the Islamic world (Mamluk cards, four suits: wands / coins / swords / polo sticks) |
| c. 1420s | Cards with trumps (trionfi) appear in northern Italy — the first ancestor of tarot |
| c. 1440–1450 | The Visconti-Sforza deck is made in Milan — the most complete early tarot to survive — hand-painted, gilded with gold leaf, a luxury for the nobility |
| c. 1450–1500 | The Tarot de Marseille takes shape and becomes the standard form for the next 300 years |
| 1500s–1700s | Tarot (Tarocchi) is widely played across Europe; the card game known as tarocchi is popular in Italy, France and Germany |
What defines the Tarot de Marseille:
The Minor Arcana number cards (Ace–10) carry no scene, only arrangements of the suit's symbol
The Major Arcana have pictures, but the detail is relatively plain
This form shaped every tarot deck that followed
A crucial point: throughout those 300 years nobody treated tarot as a tool of divination. It was a card game, much like the ancestor of today's “Fight the Landlord”.
8.2.2Stage two · The birth of the Egyptian origin story (1781)
Key figure: Court de Gébelin (1725–1784), a French Protestant pastor and scholar.
The event: in 1781, in his work “The Primitive World” (Le Monde Primitif), he published an article on tarot proposing that:
Tarot was not an Italian game at all but a survival of the ancient Egyptian Book of Thoth, a “hieroglyphic system of symbols” through which Egyptian priests passed on secret wisdom. The closeness in sound between the Hebrew “Torah” and “Tarot” proved its sacred origin as well.
What is wrong with this claim:
It rests on no historical evidence at all — pure speculation
The relationship between ancient Egyptian and Hebrew is misrepresented
The chronology does not work — Egyptian civilisation had ended more than a thousand years before tarot appeared
Its influence, however, was decisive: that single article turned tarot from “a game” into “an occult classic”. Every occult tarot system since has been built on this mistaken starting point.
The historical irony: both tarot's use in divination and its occult system grew out of a scholarly error. And yet that is precisely the point — whatever value tarot has may lie not in its “ancient origins” but in the power of this image system itself.
8.2.3Stage three · Turning to divination (1780s–1850s)
Key figure: Etteilla (born Jean-Baptiste Alliette, 1738–1791), a Frenchman and the first professional tarot reader in history.
His contribution:
He was the first person to make a living from tarot readings (“Etteilla” was his pen name, his own surname “Alliette” spelled backwards)
In 1785 he published Manière de se récréer avec le jeu de cartes nommées tarots (“How to amuse yourself with the card game called tarots”)
He designed the first tarot deck made specifically for divination — the Etteilla Tarot
He gave the Minor Arcana number cards specific meanings (in the Marseille deck they have no scene to read)
The effect: from him onwards tarot acquired both a literature and a tool for “divination”. Tarot reading is only 240 years old, counting from 1785.
8.2.4Stage four · Becoming occult (1850s)
Key figure: Eliphas Lévi (born Alphonse Louis Constant, 1810–1875), a French occultist.
His contribution:
He joined tarot to the Kabbalah as a system — proposing that the 22 Major Arcana correspond to the 22 Hebrew letters and to the 22 paths of the Tree of Life
He connected tarot with astrology, alchemy and the four elements
He put forward the classic claim that tarot is an all-encompassing book of magic
His major work: “The Doctrine and Ritual of High Magic” (Dogme et Rituel de la Haute Magie, 1856)
Historical significance: he is the true builder of the occult tarot system. Before him tarot had nothing to do with Kabbalah; after him the pairing became standard in tarot theory.
8.2.5Stage five · Systematisation (1888–1900s)
Key organisation: the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, founded in London in 1888.
What it was: the most influential Western occult order of the late 19th century; its members included the poet W. B. Yeats and the actor Frank Benson.
Its core work:
It integrated tarot, Kabbalah, astrology, alchemy and Hermeticism into one complete system of correspondences
It drew up the tables of correspondence linking the Major Arcana to astrology and the Hebrew letters (the Golden Dawn system still in use today)
It systematised the reading of cards “upright” and “reversed”
Key figures:
S. L. MacGregor Mathers (1854–1918), one of the founders, who organised the system of ritual magic
A. E. Waite (1857–1942), who took charge of the tarot project after joining
Pamela Colman Smith (1878–1951), commissioned by Waite to paint the new deck
The Golden Dawn's split after 1900 scattered its members across Europe and America and carried the tarot system out into the world. Almost every current of tarot theory in the English-speaking world traces back to this one order.
8.2.6Stage six · The birth of modern tarot (1909)
The event: in 1909 A. E. Waite and the artist Pamela Colman Smith published the Rider–Waite–Smith tarot deck, known as RWS after its publisher Rider & Company and also called the Rider-Waite deck.
The revolutionary innovation:
All 56 Minor Arcana cards were given an actual scene!
In the Tarot de Marseille the number cards are merely arrangements of symbols — the Five of Swords, for instance, is simply five sword designs. Pamela Colman Smith painted a readable story scene for every single card:
Five of Swords: a man holds three swords and looks back at two defeated figures
Three of Cups: three women raise their cups in celebration
Ten of Pentacles: a family and a dog in front of an old house
This change turned tarot from a matter of memorised meanings into reading a picture — it lowered the barrier to entry enormously and made tarot a genuinely “pictorial tool of psychology”.
The standing of RWS: of all the tarot decks in circulation in the world today, the great majority are based on its imagery and its system. It has become the de facto “standard tarot”.
That same year Waite published the Pictorial Key to the Tarot, setting out the RWS card meanings and spreads in full.
8.2.7Stage seven · Divergence and canonisation (1944)
Key figure: Aleister Crowley (1875–1947), once a member of the Golden Dawn and later expelled.
His major work: the Thoth tarot deck (published in 1944)
Its characteristics:
The artist was Lady Frieda Harris (1877–1962), who spent about five years painting it
Extremely dense Kabbalistic, astrological and alchemical symbolism, with abstract, ornate imagery
It changed the order and the correspondences of some cards — most famously, it swaps the Hebrew letter correspondences of “The Emperor” and “The Star” (Crowley's correction)
Its card meanings are more complex and more aggressive than those of RWS
The three great decks compared:
| Deck | Date | Minor Arcana | Character | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tarot de Marseille | Standardised 15th–18th century | Symbols only | The oldest form, plain in its symbolism | Studying history, traditionalists |
| RWS (the Waite deck) | 1909 | Full-scene illustration | The most popular, a complete system, the most material available | The first choice for beginners |
| The Thoth deck | 1944 | Full scenes, abstract and ornate | Dense symbolism, a complex system | Advanced readers, the Crowley school |
Note the disagreement over 8 and 11:
| Deck | Card 8 | Card 11 |
|---|---|---|
| Marseille / Thoth | Justice | Strength |
| RWS | Strength | Justice |
This is a common source of confusion, and you need to be clear about which deck you are using.
8.2.8Stage eight · Modern tarot (1950s to the present)
| Period | Development |
|---|---|
| 1950s–60s | Tarot revives in the English-speaking world and merges with the New Age movement |
| 1970s | A flood of new decks is published; tarot with feminist and ecological themes appears |
| 1980s–90s | Tarot is deeply combined with psychology, and a “tarot counselling” approach appears |
| 2000s to the present | The internet and social media popularise tarot; self-awareness practices such as the “tarot journal” and the “card of the day” appear; at the same time commercialised reading content floods the market |
The two main contemporary approaches to tarot:
| Approach | Position | Typical practice |
|---|---|---|
| The occult school | Tarot is a tool of energy and spirit | Ritual, cleansing, energy reading |
| The psychological school | Tarot is a medium for psychological projection | C. G. Jung's archetypes, narrative therapy, self-reflection |
This library takes the “psychological school plus cultural education” position: it treats tarot as a medium for cultural knowledge and self-reflection, not as a predictive tool.
8.3The structure and meaning of the deck
8.3.1The full table of the 22 Major Arcana
What follows is the RWS system, with number, name, core imagery, upright keywords, reversed keywords, astrological correspondence and Hebrew letter.
| No. | English name | Chinese name (pinyin) | Core imagery | Upright keywords | Reversed keywords | Astrology | Hebrew letter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | The Fool | Yúzhě | A traveller at the edge of a cliff | Beginnings, adventure, innocence, endless possibility | Recklessness, avoidance, hesitation | Air / Uranus | Aleph א |
| 1 | The Magician | Móshùshī | The four elemental tools laid on a table | Ability, creativity, will, capacity for action | Deceit, procrastination, ability left unused | Mercury | Bet ב |
| 2 | The High Priestess | Nǚjìsī | Between the black pillar and the white | Intuition, the unconscious, inner wisdom, mystery | Ignoring intuition, secrets, saying one thing and meaning another | the Moon | Gimel ג |
| 3 | The Empress | Huánghòu | Abundant nature | Abundance, nurture, creativity, motherhood | Dependence, blocked creativity, giving too much | Venus | Dalet ד |
| 4 | The Emperor | Huángdì | A ruler on a stone throne | Order, authority, stability, fatherhood | Tyranny, rigidity, lack of self-discipline | Aries | He ה |
| 5 | The Hierophant | Jiàohuáng | A religious authority with two keys | Tradition, teaching, belief, institutions | Rebellion, dogma, formalism | Taurus | Vau ו |
| 6 | The Lovers | Liànrén | A pair in the Garden of Eden | Union, choice, values, love and harmony | Imbalance, difficulty choosing, shirking responsibility | Gemini | Zayin ז |
| 7 | The Chariot | Zhànchē | Driving the black and white sphinxes | Will, victory, control, forward motion | Losing control, losing direction, recklessness | Cancer | Cheth ח |
| 8 | Strength | Lìliàng | A woman calming a lion | Courage, patience, gentle strength | Self-doubt, weakness, being ruled by emotion | Leo | Teth ט |
| 9 | The Hermit | Yǐnshì | An old man with a lantern | Introspection, solitude, seeking truth, guidance | Isolation, avoidance, stubborn withdrawal | Virgo | Yod י |
| 10 | Wheel of Fortune | Mìngyùn zhī lún | A turning wheel | A turning point, cycles, destiny, timing | Bad luck, resisting change, losing control | Jupiter | Kaph כ |
| 11 | Justice | Zhèngyì | A figure with sword and scales | Justice, cause and effect, balance, responsibility | Injustice, evading responsibility, imbalance | Libra | Lamed ל |
| 12 | The Hanged Man | Dàodiàorén | A man hanging upside down from a tree | Pause, a change of perspective, sacrifice, sudden insight | Deadlock, pointless sacrifice, delay | Water | Mem מ |
| 13 | Death | Sǐshén | A skeletal knight on a white horse | Ending, transformation, letting go, new life | Resisting change, stagnation, clinging to the past | Scorpio | Nun נ |
| 14 | Temperance | Jiézhì | An angel exchanging the water between two cups | Balance, adjustment, patience, the middle way | Imbalance, extremes, impatience | Sagittarius | Samekh ס |
| 15 | The Devil | Èmó | Two figures in chains | Bondage, desire, fixation, the shadow | Release, awareness, breaking free of the chains | Capricorn | Ayin ע |
| 16 | The Tower | Tǎ | A tower struck by lightning | Sudden change, collapse, awakening, truth | Avoiding the disaster, a collapse delayed | Mars | Pe פ |
| 17 | The Star | Xīngxing | A naked woman by the water | Hope, healing, guidance, faith | Disappointment, self-doubt, losing direction | Aquarius | Tzaddi צ |
| 18 | The Moon | Yuèliàng | A wolf and a dog beneath the moon | Illusion, the unconscious, unease, intuition | The fog lifting, fear released, truth surfacing | Pisces | Qoph ק |
| 19 | The Sun | Tàiyáng | A child and a horse in the sunlight | Success, joy, vitality, light | A passing cloud, over-optimism, joy delayed | the Sun | Resh ר |
| 20 | Judgement | Shěnpàn | An angel blowing a trumpet | Awakening, a summons, reckoning, rebirth | Self-criticism, avoiding the summons, regret | Fire / Pluto | Shin ש |
| 21 | The World | Shìjiè | A dancer inside a wreath | Completion, fulfilment, integration, achievement | Unfinished business, a delayed ending, no sense of closure | Saturn | Tau ת |
8.3.2The narrative structure of the Major Arcana: “the Fool's Journey”
The Major Arcana are not 22 isolated cards but one continuous story of growth — and that is where tarot's deepest appeal lies.
The story line:
Act one: Setting out (0–7) 0 The Fool — sets off in fearless ignorance 1 The Magician — discovers that he has tools 2 The High Priestess — meets inner wisdom 3 The Empress — experiences abundance and nurture 4 The Emperor — establishes order and structure 5 The Hierophant — accepts tradition and teaching 6 The Lovers — faces choice and union 7 The Chariot — moves forward on willpower Act two: Trial (8–14) 8 Strength — learns to handle inner wildness gently 9 The Hermit — withdraws alone, seeking truth 10 Wheel of Fortune — meets a turn beyond his control 11 Justice — accepts cause and effect, and responsibility 12 The Hanged Man — is forced to stop and change perspective 13 Death — goes through an utter ending and transformation 14 Temperance — learns balance and reconciliation Act three: Awakening (15–21) 15 The Devil — sees his own fixation and shadow 16 The Tower — the false structure collapses 17 The Star — recovers hope on the ruins 18 The Moon — passes through illusion and fear 19 The Sun — arrives at clear joy 20 Judgement — is summoned, looks back, awakens 21 The World — completes the integration and arrives at fulfilment (and a new beginning)
The three groups of seven cards (another common division):
| Stage | Cards | Theme |
|---|---|---|
| 8–14 | Strength → Temperance | Inner work: facing emotion, solitude, destiny, responsibility |
| 15–21 | The Devil → The World | Liberation and integration: facing the shadow, breaking illusion, arriving at wholeness |
This narrative is the most worthwhile thing tarot has to tell. It explains why tarot is thought to “map the stages of a life” — because it is, in the end, a carefully designed parable of growth.
8.3.3The Minor Arcana: the four suits
The 56 Minor Arcana fall into four suits, corresponding to the four elements:
| Suit | English | Element | Domain | Symbol | Typical work or setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wands | Wands | Fire | Action, passion, creation, career | Branches, a magic wand | Starting a business, projects, drive |
| Cups | Cups | Water | Emotion, relationships, intuition, the inner life | Cups, vessels | Romance, friendship, family |
| Swords | Swords | Air | Thought, communication, conflict, truth | Swords, language | Decisions, arguments, study |
| Pentacles | Pentacles | Earth | Matter, money, the body, practical affairs | A five-pointed coin | Finance, work, health |
Points to remember:
Fire: hot, rising, outward → action and passion
Water: cold, descending, inward → emotion and intuition
Air: moving, transmitting → thought and communication
Earth: heavy, bearing → matter and reality
The kind of question each suit answers:
| Suit | The question it answers |
|---|---|
| Wands | “What should I do?” (action) |
| Cups | “How do I feel?” (emotion) |
| Swords | “What do I think?” (thought) |
| Pentacles | “Can this be made real?” (reality) |
8.3.4The Minor Arcana: what the numbers 1–10 mean
In every suit, from Ace to 10, the number itself carries a universal meaning for that stage:
| Number | Stage | General meaning | Example (Cups) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ace (1) | A pure beginning | The element at its purest, a new start | Ace of Cups: new love, feeling welling up |
| 2 | Duality | Balance, choice, relationship, opposition | Two of Cups: mutual attraction, an alliance |
| 3 | Growth | First results, cooperation, expansion | Three of Cups: celebration, friendship, shared joy |
| 4 | Stability | Structure, security, possibly stagnation | Four of Cups: apathy, looking away |
| 5 | Conflict | Imbalance, challenge, loss, friction | Five of Cups: loss, mourning, seeing what remains |
| 6 | Harmony | Recovery, giving, transition, nostalgia | Six of Cups: nostalgia, innocent giving |
| 7 | Assessment | Introspection, choosing, persisting or letting go | Seven of Cups: illusion, too many choices |
| 8 | Strength | Effort, action, responsibility, commitment | Eight of Cups: walking away, seeking deeper meaning |
| 9 | Approaching completion | Fruit, independence, possibly excess | Nine of Cups: contentment, a wish fulfilled |
| 10 | Completion | The end of a cycle, fulfilment or a burden | Ten of Cups: emotional fulfilment, family happiness |
A mnemonic:
One begins, two chooses; three grows, four settles; five clashes, six harmonises; seven weighs, eight pushes; nine nears fulfilment, ten concludes.
8.3.5The court cards: 16 in all
Each suit has four court cards, sixteen in total:
| Rank | English | Chinese (pinyin) | Represents | Maturity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Page | Page | Shìcóng | The element's beginner / messages / learning | Beginner |
| Knight | Knight | Qíshì | The element's doer / pursuit | Action |
| Queen | Queen | Wánghòu | Mastery of the element within | Inner maturity |
| King | King | Guówáng | Mastery of the element in the outer world | Outer maturity |
The sixteen court cards as personalities:
| Wands (Fire) | Cups (Water) | Swords (Air) | Pentacles (Earth) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Page | The curious, eager beginner | The sensitive, dreamy learner | The studious, observant watcher | The steady, willing newcomer |
| Knight | The impulsive, adventurous doer | The romantic, passionate pursuer | The decisive, direct debater | The dependable, diligent executor |
| Queen | The confident, magnetic one at the helm | The gentle, empathic nurturer | The clear-eyed, independent thinker | The practical, warm homemaker |
| King | The far-sighted leader | The emotionally mature supporter | The rational, authoritative judge | The prosperous, steady manager |
The two ways to read a court card (important):
| Reading | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Pointing to a person | The card stands for a specific person (yourself, the other party, a third person) |
| Pointing to a quality | The card stands for a quality or attitude that is needed, or that is showing itself |
Modern tarot leans towards the second reading, because pointing at a specific person easily leads to misjudgement and strains relationships.
8.3.6The symbolic system of elements and numbers
How the four elements layer into a card:
Suit (the element's domain) × number (its stage of development) = the card's combined meaning
Example: Cups (Water / emotion) + 5 (conflict) = the Five of Cups = loss and mourning at the emotional level Example: Wands (Fire / action) + 8 (strength) = the Eight of Wands = action advancing fast, news arriving
The “alchemical” layer of tarot: some systems also assign the Major Arcana to three alchemical stages:
| Stage | Cards | Alchemical process | Colour |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nigredo (blackening) | 13 Death, 15 The Devil, 16 The Tower | Breaking down, putrefaction | Black |
| Albedo (whitening) | 17 The Star, 18 The Moon | Purification, washing | White |
| Rubedo (reddening) | 19 The Sun, 20 Judgement, 21 The World | Completion, sublimation | Red |
8.3.7Hebrew letters and the Kabbalistic correspondence
22 Major Arcana ↔ 22 Hebrew letters ↔ the 22 paths of the Tree of Life
The 22 Hebrew letters:
א Aleph ב Bet ג Gimel ד Dalet ה He ו Vau ז Zayin ח Cheth ט Teth י Yod כ Kaph ל Lamed מ Mem נ Nun ס Samekh ע Ayin פ Pe צ Tzaddi ק Qoph ר Resh ש Shin ת Tau
The three levels of the Tree of Life:
| Level | Name | Meaning | Major Arcana |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | The divine triangle | The transcendent first principles | 0? / 1, 2, 3 |
| Second | The psychological level | The structure of mind and emotion | 4–9 |
| Third | The level of action | Manifestation in the material world | 10–21 |
A scholarly note: different schools (the Golden Dawn versus Crowley) disagree on particular correspondences. The most famous disagreement is Crowley's exchange of the letter correspondences of “The Emperor” (He) and “The Star” (Tzaddi). When using Kabbalistic correspondences, choose one system and say clearly which.
8.4How it is used
8.4.1The principles of asking a question (the most important step)
The quality of a tarot reading depends to a great extent on the quality of the question.
Four standards for a good question:
| Standard | A good question | A poor question |
|---|---|---|
| Open-ended (not a yes/no question) | “How can I improve this relationship?” | “Will he come back?” |
| Focused on yourself (not on controlling others) | “How can I give a better account of myself at this interview?” | “Will the interviewer like me?” |
| Specific (not vague) | “What are the key challenges for this project over the next three months?” | “How will my career turn out?” |
| Leaves room for action | “What options do I have?” | “Am I destined to fail?” |
Three things you should never ask the cards:
Other people's private lives (“what is my colleague saying about me behind my back?”)
Anything that replaces professional judgement (concrete medical, legal or financial decisions)
Predictions of life and death (lifespan or the outcome of an illness, in any form)
8.4.2The procedure
The standard procedure (in the RWS tradition):
| Step | Action | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Set your intention | Make the question clear and repeat it silently |
| 2 | Shuffle | Shuffle with both hands until it feels “ready” (there is no objective standard; this is ritual) |
| 3 | Cut the deck | Cut with the non-dominant hand (some schools omit this) |
| 4 | Draw | Draw as many cards as the spread requires, one at a time |
| 5 | Lay out the cards | Place them in the positions the spread defines |
| 6 | Turn them over | Reveal them all |
| 7 | Interpret | First card by card, then as a whole, and finally bring it together |
A note on “randomness”:
In theory the mechanism is random — shuffling and drawing are both random processes. C. G. Jung's theory of synchronicity holds that such “meaningful coincidences” are not causal connections but non-causal correspondences between a psychological state and an external event.
This is a philosophical assumption, not a scientific conclusion. But it does at least explain why tarot “seems to work” — because the reading is done by the querent themselves.
8.4.3Upright and reversed
The practice: the cards keep the orientation they had when drawn, so when they are turned over they may be “right way up” (upright) or “upside down” (reversed).
Four schools of reading reversals:
| School | Meaning of a reversal |
|---|---|
| Weakening | A weaker version of the upright meaning |
| Blockage | The upright meaning is blocked or delayed |
| Opposite | The opposite of the upright meaning |
| Internalisation | The energy turns inward (onto the psychological plane) |
| No reversals at all (a fifth school) | Upright readings only (the Marseille tradition, and some modern readers) |
Two things to keep in mind about reversals:
Schools differ widely in how they read reversals, so a reader should be explicit about which one they are using
Weakening and blockage are the gentlest readings and the least likely to provoke anxiety
8.4.4Common spreads
Spread 1: the single card (a daily draw)
┌─────┐ │ 1 │ Today's theme / the energy of this moment └─────┘
Use: daily awareness and a simple prompt for the moment. Good for an everyday, casual draw.
Spread 2: the three-card spread (the classic beginner's spread)
Version A: the timeline
┌─────────┬─────────┬─────────┐ │ 1 │ 2 │ 3 │ │ Past │ Present │ Future │ └─────────┴─────────┴─────────┘
Version B: situational analysis
┌───────────┬───────────┬───────────┐ │ 1 │ 2 │ 3 │ │ Situation │ Action │ Outcome │ └───────────┴───────────┴───────────┘
Version C: the choice spread
┌─────────┐ ┌─────────┐
│ 2 │ │ 3 │
│ Option A│ │ Option B│
└─────────┘ └─────────┘
┌──────────────┐
│ 1 │
│ Current state│
└──────────────┘Spread 3: the Celtic Cross (10 cards)
The classic and most complete of the large spreads:
┌─────┐
│ 5 │
└─────┘
┌─────┐ ┌─────┐ ┌─────┐ ┌─────┐
│ 4 │ │1 / 2│ │ 6 │ │ 10 │
└─────┘ └─────┘ └─────┘ └─────┘
┌─────┐
│ 3 │
└─────┘
┌─────┐ ┌─────┐ ┌─────┐
│ 7 │ │ 8 │ │ 9 │
└─────┘ └─────┘ └─────┘| Position | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 1 | The present situation / the core issue |
| 2 | The challenge / the obstacle crossing it (laid across card 1) |
| 3 | The subconscious basis / the root |
| 4 | The past / an influence that is now leaving |
| 5 | The conscious level / your goal or ideal |
| 6 | The near future |
| 7 | Your own attitude / where you stand |
| 8 | The outer environment / other people's influence |
| 9 | Hope and fear |
| 10 | The likely outcome |
A suggested reading order: 1 → 2 → 3 → 4 → 5 → 6 → then 7–8–9 as the “background layer” → and 10 last.
Spread 4: the relationship spread (two people)
┌────────────┐ ┌────────────┐
│ 2 │ │ 3 │
│ Partner │ │ Future │
└────────────┘ └────────────┘
┌──────────────┐
│ 1 │
│ Relationship │
│ now │
└──────────────┘A rational note: a relationship spread should not be used to identify a third party, to pass judgement on anyone's loyalty, or to assert an outcome such as “will they break up, will they marry”. Neutral questions work better — “what is the current state of the relationship”, “how does each of us feel”, “which direction could improve it”.
Other common spreads
| Spread | Cards | Use |
|---|---|---|
| The two-options spread | 5 | Comparing two alternatives |
| The monthly spread | 4 | The shape of the four weeks of a month |
| The chakra spread | 7 | Physical and emotional states mapped to seven energy centres |
| The Tree of Life spread | 10 | A full analysis on the Kabbalistic structure |
| The annual-wheel spread | 12/13 | An outlook on the twelve months of a year |
8.4.5How to read: the five-layer method
This is what turns drawing cards into a reading. The beginner's most common confusion is: “I have drawn the cards — now what?”
The five layers:
| Layer | What it covers | The question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Layer 1: the card itself | What the card means on its own | “What is this card saying?” |
| Layer 2: the position | Where it fell in the spread | “How does its meaning change in this position?” |
| Layer 3: relations between the cards | How it relates to neighbouring or opposing cards | “Do they echo each other or clash?” |
| Layer 4: the overall pattern | The overall colour, the distribution of elements, the ratio of Major to Minor Arcana | “Does the whole lean towards action or stagnation, feeling or reason?” |
| Layer 5: back to the question | Everything brought together as an answer to the question asked | “What does this mean for my question? What can I do?” |
Layer 4 in practice: counting
| What to look at | How to read it |
|---|---|
| A high proportion of Major Arcana | A major life-stage issue rather than a small everyday matter |
| One suit dominates | The issue sits in that domain (Wands = action / Cups = feeling / Swords = thought / Pentacles = the material) |
| Mostly upright / mostly reversed | Smooth / obstructed |
| Many court cards | Other people and their attitudes are involved |
| Repeated numbers (three “5”s, say) | Points to that number's stage theme (5 = conflict) |
8.4.6A full example: reading three cards
Example: the question is “What should I pay most attention to in this new project?” The draw: Eight of Swords (upright) · Three of Wands (upright) · Six of Pentacles (reversed)
Step one: the cards on their own
| Position | Card | Core meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Situation | Eight of Swords | Feeling constrained, self-limiting, unable to see a way out |
| 2 Action | Three of Wands | Foresight, waiting for results, widening your horizon |
| 3 Outcome | Six of Pentacles (reversed) | Giving and return out of balance, resources distributed unevenly |
Step two: the positions
The situation is the Eight of Swords — a psychological constraint at the start of the project, which may be self-doubt rather than a real obstacle
The action is the Three of Wands — you need to lengthen your view and look at the long term rather than at what is immediately in front of you
The outcome is the Six of Pentacles reversed — unless something changes, effort and return may fall out of balance
Step three: relations between the cards
Eight of Swords (air / constrained thought) → Three of Wands (fire / expansion outward): from “friction turned inward” to “looking outward” is a path of transformation
Three of Wands → Six of Pentacles reversed: a warning to watch that resources are shared evenly as you expand
Step four: the overall pattern
Element distribution: one air, one fire, one earth → balanced, so the issue is all-round
No Major Arcana → these are everyday matters, with no major turning point in life involved
Two upright, one reversed → broadly smooth, but with one point to watch
No court cards → the main issue is your own state, not other people
Step five: back to the question
Taken together, the greatest resistance in this project may come from your own psychological limits (Eight of Swords) rather than from external conditions. The suggestion is to lengthen your view and look at long-term value (Three of Wands), while keeping an eye on whether effort and return stay in balance, so that you do not give too much on one side (Six of Pentacles reversed).
⚠️ Note: the example above is a demonstration of method, showing the chain of reasoning in a reading. It is not a prediction, and not a judgement about how the project will turn out. In an actual tarot consultation, the final “meaning” is confirmed mainly by the querent themselves.
8.5Tarot and the Eastern systems compared
This section sets the two systems side by side.
8.5.1The symbol systems compared
| Dimension | The Eastern system | Western Tarot |
|---|---|---|
| Basic symbols | Yin-Yang, the Five Elements, the Heavenly Stems, the Earthly Branches | The four elements, numbers, image archetypes |
| Number of symbols | 10 stems + 12 branches = 60 combinations | 22 Major Arcana + 56 Minor Arcana = 78 |
| Structural logic | Cyclical (the 60 Jia-Zi cycle) | Narrative (the Fool's Journey) |
| Core mechanism | Generation and overcoming (a network of relations) | Symbolism (association with images) |
| View of time | Endless recurrence | Linear growth |
| Correspondence system | Five Elements — organs — seasons — directions | Four elements — zodiac — alchemy — Kabbalah |
8.5.2What each system is good for
| What you want to ask | The system that fits | Why |
|---|---|---|
| “What kind of person am I?” | Bazi | Bazi is a structural description |
| “What is the general rhythm of my life?” | Bazi + Major Luck | It has a ten-year cycle framework |
| “How will this matter develop?” | LiuYao | Event-oriented, with the idea of the timing of an answer |
| “How should I face this situation now?” | Tarot | State-oriented, centred on the present |
| “What is the state of my relationship with this person?” | Tarot or Synastry | Tarot reads the present state, synastry reads the structure |
| “What is today's energy?” | Tarot (a single card) | Light and everyday |
| “What should be done at which solar term?” | Solar Terms | Phenology and the farming calendar |
A practical conclusion:
The Eastern system is good at structure and cycles; tarot is good at the present and at choices. This is not a question of which is more accurate, but of different kinds of question suiting different tools.
8.5.3Three underlying ideas they share
Set the surface aside and the two systems turn out to be strikingly similar at a deeper level:
| Shared idea | As the East puts it | As the West puts it |
|---|---|---|
| Everything is made of basic elements | The Five Elements (metal, wood, water, fire, earth) | The four elements (fire, earth, air, water) plus a fifth, aether |
| The elements interact by generation and overcoming | Mutual generation and mutual overcoming | Generation and overcoming (in alchemy, “union and separation”) |
| Opposites form a unity | Yin-Yang | Pairs (sun / moon, king / queen) |
| The human being is the universe in miniature | The unity of Heaven and humanity | “As above, so below” (Hermeticism) |
| Symbols can reflect an inner state | Drawing analogies from images | Archetypal symbolism (C. G. Jung) |
The comparison itself is fascinating: two entirely independent civilisations both developed systems for describing a complex world with a limited set of symbols. That suggests a shared tendency in human cognition rather than a “truth about the universe”.
8.5.4What we do not recommend: blending the two
We explicitly advise against mixing the two systems together, as in these examples:
| The mixed-up practice | The problem |
|---|---|
| “Reading tarot cards against the Five Elements of a Bazi chart” | There is no theoretical basis for the correspondences; it is a patchwork |
| “Tarot gave me a Sword, so this year I am offending the White Tiger” | The concepts are misaligned: Swords are the air element and have no correspondence with the White Tiger (metal) |
| “Cast the Bazi chart first, then use tarot to fill in the details” | The two have different views of time and cannot be layered |
The right approach: use them separately, each as a system in its own right. Take whichever one you find more convincing rather than forcing them together.
8.6Why tarot “feels accurate”
Following the same logic as Chapter 06, we should be equally honest here about the mechanism.
8.6.1Four main psychological mechanisms
| Mechanism | What it is | How it shows up in tarot |
|---|---|---|
| The Barnum effect | Vague, universal descriptions make people feel they are “exactly about me” | “You stand at a crossroads of choice” — who does not? |
| Projection | Reading your own inner state into an ambiguous external object | The principle behind the Rorschach inkblot test; when you see The Tower, what collapse comes to mind? |
| The experience of synchronicity | A coincidence is given meaning | “I was just thinking about changing jobs and I drew the Eight of Wands” |
| Narrative construction | Weaving random images into a coherent story | The human brain is naturally good at telling stories |
8.6.2The most valuable part of tarot: the projection mechanism
This is what sets tarot apart from other divination systems:
The images in tarot are ambiguous, many-layered and charged with feeling. Faced with The Hanged Man, a person has to decide for themselves what that card means to them.
The very act of deciding has value in itself. It gives a vague feeling a concrete shape, so that it can be thought about, discussed and faced.
Psychological parallels:
The mechanism is similar to that of the Rorschach inkblot test
The approach is close to that of narrative therapy
It is consistent with expressive arts therapies such as projective drawing
The most reasonable way to place tarot, then, is this:
| Placement | What it means |
|---|---|
| ✅ A tool for self-awareness | It helps you see your present state and your confusion clearly |
| ✅ A medium for conversation | It gives a way into topics that are hard to raise |
| ✅ A framework for making meaning | It arranges scattered feelings into a structure you can think about |
| ❌ A prediction tool | It cannot foretell the future |
| ❌ A substitute for deciding | It cannot decide for you |
8.6.3The conclusion that matches the Eastern system
| Point | What we conclude |
|---|---|
| Where the “accuracy” comes from | Not from any predictive power in the symbols themselves, but from the reader's projection and construction during the reading |
| The real value | It offers a structured framework for reflection |
| The greatest risk | Mistaking the framework for fact, and so giving up your own judgement |
8.7Biographies
8.7.1Court de Gébelin (1725–1784)
Full name: Antoine Court de Gébelin. A French Protestant pastor, scholar and Freemason.
Principal work: Le Monde Primitif (The Primitive World, 1773–1784), in nine volumes
Key contribution: in 1781, in that book, he put forward the hypothesis that tarot descended from the ancient Egyptian Book of Thoth.
Historical assessment:
He was a serious scholar, working on linguistics, mythology and ancient civilisations, yet this particular speculation had no documentary basis
He was writing at the height of “Egyptomania” — Napoleon's expedition to Egypt came in 1798, but the fashion had begun earlier — and his hypothesis suited the cultural mood of the day
His mistake, quite unintentionally, launched the entire occult tarot tradition
Historical standing: the greatest “butterfly effect” figure in tarot history. One error of scholarship gave rise to two hundred years of occult industry.
8.7.2Etteilla (1738–1791)
Real name: Jean-Baptiste Alliette. “Etteilla” is his surname spelled backwards, and the “ancient Egyptian mystery name” he claimed for himself — an echo of the Egyptian-origin theory then in vogue.
Identity: a French diviner, and the first professional tarot reader in history.
Principal works:
Manière de se récréer avec le jeu de cartes nommées tarots (How to Amuse Yourself with the Card Game Called Tarot, 1785)
the Etteilla Tarot (1789)
Contributions:
the first person to take up tarot reading as a profession, running a divination salon
the first tarot deck designed specifically for divination
he gave the numbered Minor Arcana specific meanings, where the Marseille number cards carry no scene
he introduced the “spread” as a working practice
Historical standing: the practical founder of tarot divination. Before him, tarot had nothing to do with divination.
Controversy: his system of divination was shot through with “Egyptian imaginings” — he in fact knew nothing of ancient Egypt — and his own life was a long struggle that ended in poverty. It is often cited as an example of how a diviner cannot vouch for himself.
8.7.3Eliphas Lévi (1810–1875)
Real name: Alphonse Louis Constant. He began as a deacon in the French Catholic Church, then turned to occultism and took the Frenchified Hebrew name “Eliphas Lévi” as his pen name.
Principal works: Dogme et Rituel de la Haute Magie (Dogma and Ritual of High Magic, 1856) and Histoire de la Magie (History of Magic, 1860)
Core contributions:
He joined tarot to the Kabbalah as a system, proposing that the 22 Major Arcana correspond to the 22 Hebrew letters and to the 22 paths of the Tree of Life
he set tarot inside the full framework of Hermeticism
he linked tarot to astrology, alchemy and the four elements
he produced the classic claim that “tarot is a universal key”
his work shaped every later Western occult current, from the Golden Dawn to Crowley
Historical standing: the true architect of the occult tarot system. The core framework of every tarot theory in the English-speaking world today can be traced back to his writings.
A famous line: “Tarot is a real book of philosophy and religion, a summary of all ancient teaching… It is a key that opens every door.”
A scholarly caveat: the “tarot–Kabbalah” correspondence he insisted on is not a historical fact — fifteenth-century tarot carries no Kabbalistic symbols — but a systematic construction. That construction was itself highly creative, and it became the core of tarot theory.
8.7.4S. L. MacGregor Mathers (1854–1918)
Full name: Samuel Liddell MacGregor Mathers. A British occultist and one of the three founders of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn.
Contributions:
he organised and systematised the Golden Dawn's table of tarot correspondences (Major Arcana ↔ astrology ↔ Hebrew letters ↔ paths)
he wrote the order's ritual-magic texts, among them a tarot manual of lasting influence
he translated and edited a great many medieval magical texts, such as the Key of Solomon
Historical standing: the key figure in the technical standardisation of tarot. The “Major Arcana correspondence table” found in textbooks today is largely the product of his work — and the Golden Dawn's.
How it ended: he died in poverty in 1918, during the influenza pandemic.
8.7.5A. E. Waite (1857–1942)
Identity: a British scholar and occultist, and the initiator of the RWS tarot deck.
Principal works:
The Pictorial Key to the Tarot (1911)
The Holy Kabbalah
Core contributions:
he commissioned Pamela Colman Smith to draw the RWS tarot deck (1909) and designed the imagery on every card
he pioneered fully illustrated scenes for the Minor Arcana, the single most important technical innovation in tarot history
he adjusted the order of the Major Arcana, fixing 8 = Strength and 11 = Justice, the reverse of the Marseille deck
his Pictorial Key to the Tarot set out the card meanings systematically and became the later standard
Temperament and stance:
he was a scholar rather than a practitioner — he did little divination and cared far more about the system of symbols
he kept his distance from “spiritualist” and “séance” practices and the like
his readings of the cards were relatively conservative and moralising — he read the Devil, for instance, as “bondage to material desire”
Historical standing: the father of modern tarot. The most widely used tarot deck in the world today is the one he devised.
8.7.6Pamela Colman Smith (1878–1951)
Identity: a British illustrator nicknamed “Pixie”, and the actual artist of the RWS tarot deck.
Background:
born in London; she spent part of her childhood in Jamaica and the United States
she studied at the Pratt Institute in New York
she took part in stage design for the Irish Literary Theatre, the Abbey Theatre in Dublin
she exhibited her illustrations and was praised as “an artist with a gift for synaesthesia”
Contributions:
she drew the images for all 78 cards on her own — finished in 1909, in about six months
her images set the visual language of modern tarot — the Hanged Man, the Tower and the Sun are still drawn the world over from her compositions
A historical regret:
her fee was extremely low — a few tens of pounds, by one account — and for a long time she received no proper credit: the deck is usually called “Rider-Waite”, with her name last
she was poor in her later years and died almost forgotten
in recent years scholars and the tarot community have begun, systematically, to restore her name, and more and more publications now write “Rider-Waite-Smith” or “Smith-Waite”
Historical standing: the creator of tarot's visual language. It is fair to say that without Pamela Colman Smith there would be no tarot as we know it today.
One suggestion: when introducing tarot, it is worth using the full name “Rider-Waite-Smith” as a matter of course and giving Pamela Colman Smith the space she deserves. It is a small point, but it shows care and fairness.
8.7.7Aleister Crowley (1875–1947)
Identity: a British occultist, poet and mountaineer, and the most controversial occult figure of the twentieth century.
Background:
he joined the Golden Dawn and left amid internal conflict
he founded the occult system of Thelema, whose central precept runs “Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law”
the press called him “the wickedest man in the world” — a reputation he promoted himself
Principal work: the Thoth Tarot (1944)
What distinguishes the Thoth deck:
the artist was Lady Frieda Harris (1877–1962), who took about five years over the 78 cards
the symbolism is extraordinarily dense — Kabbalah, astrology, alchemy and Egyptian myth all folded in together
the colour is sumptuous and the compositions abstract
he corrected some of the correspondences: most famously, the Hebrew letters for the Emperor (He) and the Star (Tzaddi) were swapped
the card meanings are more direct and more forceful than in the RWS deck
Historical standing: alongside Waite, one of the two wellsprings of modern tarot. The RWS deck took the popular route; the Thoth deck took the route of deep symbolism.
8.7.8Lady Frieda Harris (1877–1962)
Identity: a British painter and the artist of the Thoth tarot deck. She came from the aristocracy; her husband was Sir Percy Harris.
Contributions:
working with Crowley, she spent about five years (1938–1943) painting all 78 Thoth cards
to render Crowley's symbolic intentions accurately, she taught herself astrology and Kabbalah
she used projective geometry, which gives the images their distinctive sense of space
she paid all the costs out of her own pocket
Historical assessment: half of the Thoth deck's artistic achievement is hers. She and Pamela Colman Smith are the two women artists long underrated in tarot history.
8.7.9C. G. Jung (1875–1961)
Identity: a Swiss psychologist and the founder of analytical psychology. He was not a tarot researcher, but his theories are the key to understanding tarot.
Core concepts:
| Concept | Explanation | Relation to tarot |
|---|---|---|
| The collective unconscious | The inherited layer of psychic structure shared by all human beings | The source of the “shared charge” that tarot images carry |
| Archetype | Universal figures within the collective unconscious | The Fool = the eternal youth, the Empress = the great mother, Death = transformation |
| Synchronicity | “Meaningful coincidence”, a non-causal correspondence | The theoretical explanation of why tarot “works” |
| Projection | Attributing an inner state to an external object | The psychological mechanism of tarot reading |
On synchronicity: Jung worked with the Nobel laureate in physics Wolfgang Pauli; in 1952 they co-authored The Interpretation of Nature and the Psyche, a systematic discussion of the concept. Jung held that certain events are linked not by cause and effect but by correspondence in meaning.
Historical standing: he gave tarot its modern psychological clothing. The mainstream position today — that tarot is a tool of psychological projection — begins with Jung.
A scholarly caveat: synchronicity is not a scientific theory; it cannot itself be falsified. Jung offered it as a philosophical framework for discussing phenomena that “cannot be explained by cause and effect yet carry psychological meaning”.
8.8Rational use and disclaimer
Tarot's “orientation to the present” makes its readings all the more likely to be taken as a verdict on a current situation, and so it needs clear rational caveats and disclaimers even more than other methods do.
8.8.1Why tarot calls for a rational reading
| Reason | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Its focus on the present is stronger | Tarot's “orientation to the present” makes the result more visceral — “your situation: the Tower” is more alarming than “your chart has a Seven Killings” |
| Readers are more easily swayed by emotion | Tarot's audience is mostly young and easily moved by emotionally charged content, so a sense of distance matters more |
8.8.5Disclaimer
A rational note: Tarot is an image-based symbol system that originated in the West; it is a tool for cultural experience and self-reflection. Drawing the cards is a random process, and its readings have no predictive power and no empirical scientific basis. Everything in this library is an introduction to traditional culture and a form of inspiration through psychological projection; it does not represent any factual judgement about you or anyone else. Please do not base any major life decision on it — marriage, career, investment, medical treatment or otherwise. If you are facing psychological distress, please seek professional counselling or medical help.
8.9Chapter summary
| Point | Details |
|---|---|
| The truth about its origin | A fifteenth-century Italian card game (Tarocchi), not ancient Egypt; the “Egyptian origin” story comes from an error of scholarship in 1781 |
| Where divination begins | In 1785 Etteilla designed the first tarot deck for divination |
| The occult turning point | In 1856 Eliphas Lévi joined tarot to the Kabbalah |
| Systematisation | In 1888 the Golden Dawn built a complete system of correspondences |
| The birth of modern tarot | The 1909 RWS deck (devised by Waite, drawn by Pamela Colman Smith), the first to illustrate every Minor Arcana card with a scene |
| The three great decks | Marseille (oldest), RWS (most popular), Thoth (most complex) |
| Structure | 22 Major Arcana + 56 Minor Arcana (4 suits × 14 cards) |
| What the Major Arcana really are | One continuous story of growth — the “Fool's Journey” |
| Core procedure | Ask a question → shuffle → draw → lay out the spread → the five-layer reading |
| Contrast with the Eastern systems | The Eastern systems look at “structure and cycle”; tarot looks at “the present and choice” |
| Its real value | Projection and self-awareness (the psychological school), not prediction |
| Minimum standards of phrasing | No claims about outcomes, no predictions of death or illness, no naming third parties, no paid offers to “dissolve” a bad omen |