Culture & Rational Reading

Destiny arts did not appear out of nowhere. Every one of their concepts answers to a core proposition in Chinese philosophy.

6.1.1Yin-Yang: the archetype of all relationship

Source: The Book of Changes (Zhou Yi), “Great Commentary”: “One Yin and one Yang — this is what is called the Dao.”

Core content:

Key insight: Yin-Yang is not a division into “good and bad” but a complementarity of two natures. Yin is not negative and Yang is not positive. This is where people most often go wrong in understanding destiny arts.

6.1.2The Five Elements: a model of relationship and process

Source: The Book of Documents (Shang Shu), “The Great Plan”: “The Five Elements: the first is Water, the second Fire, the third Wood, the fourth Metal, the fifth Earth.”

Why five? The Five Elements are not “five substances” but five states of motion, five types of relationship:

The core of the relationships among the Five Elements:

Generation (a cycle): Wood → Fire → Earth → Metal → Water → Wood
Restraint (with one step between): Wood → Earth → Water → Fire → Metal → Wood

The Five Elements are not “substances” but “functions”. Once you see this, you see why destiny arts can describe a complicated life with only five symbols — because what they describe is not “things” but “processes and relationships”.

6.1.3The unity of Heaven and humanity: time and the human being share one structure

Core proposition: a human being shares one structure with Heaven and Earth; the rhythms of a person's life answer to the rhythms of Heaven and Earth.

How it appears in destiny arts:

• –

  The state of Heaven and Earth at the moment of birth (the Stem-Branch), assumed to answer to this person's “life structure”

• –

  The Solar Terms (the rhythms of Heaven and Earth) determine the Month Command (the strength or weakness of a person's Five Elements)

• –

  Major Luck and Annual Fortune (cycles of time) correspond to the rises and falls of a life

A philosophical assessment:

• –

  It embodies the ancient Chinese “organic worldview” and stands in sharp contrast to the Western “mechanical worldview”

• –

  Its value: it stresses that a person cannot exist apart from their environment, and that one should follow the rhythms of nature

• –

  Its limitation: “correspondence” here is analogical reasoning, not causal reasoning

6.1.4The theory of qi: thinking in continuities

Core concept: qi is the continuous medium of which all things are made; Heaven and Earth are filled with qi, and its gathering and scattering decides the arising and passing of all things.

How it appears in destiny arts:

• –

  “The qi of the Five Elements” — the Five Elements are five states of qi

• –

  “Prosperous, Strong, Resting, Imprisoned, Dead” — how the strength of qi rises and falls

• –

  “Adjustment” — tuning the cold and warmth, the dryness and dampness of qi

Philosophical significance: the theory of qi led Chinese thinkers to stop asking “what is the essence of a thing” and to ask instead “what is the state of its qi”. This is a relational, process-based way of thinking that has something in common with contemporary systems theory.

6.1.5The image-and-number tradition: a universe rendered in symbols

Core methods:

• –

  Taking images: drawing features out of concrete phenomena (for example, “Qian is Heaven, the father, the head, the horse”)

• –

  Classifying by analogy: grouping things with similar features into one class

• –

  Inference: reasoning within the classification system

Strengths:

• –

  Extremely inclusive — anything at all can be matched to a hexagram or an element

• –

  Easy to memorise and pass on — mnemonic verses and tables of correspondences

Weaknesses:

• –

  Unfalsifiable — since the correspondences can be extended without limit, any conclusion can find its evidence

• –

  It easily slides into far-fetched matching — precisely why Wang Bi (Three Kingdoms) wanted to “sweep away the images” and Zhang Nan (Ming) to “cut away the overgrowth”

6.1.6The Mean and central harmony: the highest value

Core proposition: “Central harmony is what matters most.”

How it appears in destiny arts:

• –

  The most desirable state for a Bazi chart is the free flow of the Five Elements, in balance and without bias

• –

  The Pattern school speaks of “forming a Pattern”, the strength-and-weakness school of “balance”; at bottom both are after “harmony”

• –

  “A chart is prized for what ails it” (Zhang Nan) is a deliberate inversion: a chart with no ailment is mediocre, and skill shows only where there is an ailment and a remedy for it

Cultural meaning: this embodies the Chinese conviction that going too far is as wrong as falling short — the best is not the strongest but the most balanced.

The purpose of this section is neither to “criticise” nor to “defend”, but to present things as they are. Only by understanding where destiny arts end can we face them rationally.

6.2.1What scientific method requires

For a theory to be called “scientific”, it has to meet these requirements:

Conclusion: destiny arts do not meet the basic requirements of modern science. They belong to the realm of ancient philosophy and folk culture.

6.2.2Several explanations for why destiny arts seem to “come true”

People really do often find destiny arts “very accurate”. Psychology offers several explanations:

These effects are real psychological mechanisms. Understanding them is more worthwhile than simply “believing” or “not believing”.

6.2.3Three fundamental problems destiny arts cannot solve

6.2.4Where destiny arts are in fact “scientific”

This is not an attempt at whitewashing; it is simply the case:

The key distinction:

• –

  The calendrical part (Stem-Branch, Solar Terms, True Solar Time) — rests on a rigorous scientific basis

• –

  The inferential part (Ten Gods, Patterns, the Useful God, judgements of good and ill fortune) — belongs to philosophy and folklore

• –

  In a destiny-arts book the two parts are mixed together, and the reader has to tell them apart

Setting aside the argument over whether it “works”, destiny arts have at least the following kinds of value today:

6.3.1Value as cultural heritage

• –

  The 24 Solar Terms are inscribed on the list of humanity's intangible cultural heritage — a cultural possession of all humankind

• –

  Destiny-arts texts such as Sanming Tonghui, Yuanhai Ziping and Ditiansui are important sources for the intellectual history of ancient China

• –

  Stem-Branch day-counting and zodiac culture are woven deep into everyday Chinese speech (“till the year of the monkey and the month of the horse”, “one's zodiac year”)

6.3.2Value as mental training

• –

  Symbolic thinking: describing a complex system with a limited set of symbols

• –

  Systems thinking: the generation and restraint of the Five Elements is a model of a “network of relationships”

• –

  Dialectical thinking: “at its peak, strength must decline”, “a clash sets things in motion” — the idea that opposites turn into one another

6.3.3Value as psychological support

It matters that we acknowledge this: many people find psychological reassurance in reading a destiny-arts interpretation. That is not “superstition”; it is:

But there is a condition: it must not become an excuse to give up practical action, nor should a negative reading be allowed to tip you into anxiety.

6.3.4Value in social life and cultural consumption

• –

  Zodiac talk is common currency in Chinese social life

• –

  Teas, foods and handicrafts themed to the solar terms, and other cultural products

• –

  Light, entertainment-oriented consumption of destiny-arts topics

6.4.1The reader's “three dos and three don'ts”

6.4.2What to do with a judgement of “ill fortune”

This is the situation that most needs handling.

The right steps:

• 1.

  Identify the language: decide whether it is “descriptive” or “assertive”

  • Descriptive: “Traditional theory holds that this combination indicates greater pressure” → worth knowing about
  • Assertive: “You will certainly suffer a great disaster this year” → this is not destiny arts, this is intimidation

• 1.

  Ask for the basis: where does this claim come from? Is it the reading of one school alone? Is there a contrary account?

• 1.

  Check the motive: if the other person then tries to sell you a “resolution” service, be on your guard at once

• 1.

  Return to reality: turn your attention to what you can control (managing your health, planning your finances, communicating in your relationships)

6.4.3On “resolution” and “improving your luck”

This is a boundary that has to be drawn clearly:

The key test: be wary of anything that asks you to pay to “remove” an ill omen. The genuine traditional literature contains no such logic of “paying to avert disaster” — that is a later commercial invention.

6.4.4Guidelines for how the content is phrased

This library follows the guidelines below in how it phrases things.

Looked at objectively, destiny arts also carry the stamp of their times, and some of their content should be clearly criticised or set aside:

6.5.1Content that must be criticised

6.5.2Dissecting “overcoming the husband” and “overcoming the wife”

This is one of the most socially harmful notions in traditional destiny arts, and it needs to be addressed on its own:

The traditional claim: women with a certain kind of Bazi (a heavy Hurting Officer, say, or Seven Killings sitting in the day branch) “overcome the husband” and bring him misfortune.

The facts one has to know:

• 1.

  The logic does not hold: it attributes a problem in a relationship to the woman alone, which is the logical fallacy of single-cause attribution.

• 2.

  Where it came from: the values of a patriarchal society, with no bearing on the “technique” of chart reading itself.

• 3.

  The harm it does now: it lays psychological burden and reputational damage on many women and their families, and misattributes many marital problems.

• 4.

  The right alternative: where a relationship has a problem, look at the pattern of interaction between the two people, not at a label stuck on one of them.

Where this library stands: under no circumstances do we use phrases such as “overcoming the husband”, “overcoming the wife”, “overcoming the parents” or “overcoming the children”. This is not a matter of “how strict the review is” but of basic values.

Chinese destiny arts have a history of more than two thousand years. They were born in an age when humanity could not yet understand the world through science, and they carry the whole of the ancients' imagining and questioning about time, nature and fate.

There is something real in them — the precise calendrical calculations, the close observation of seasonal phenomena, the attempt to classify types of character.

There are also the limits of their age — fatalism, ideas of rank, gender prejudice.

The one thing it should never do is make a decision in a person's place.

Today we have atomic clocks precise enough to record the minute of a birth; we have psychology to study how character forms; we have relationship research to study how a relationship is sustained.

The place of destiny arts should be an exhibit in a museum of culture, not an instrument on an operating table.

It is a key for understanding how our ancestors thought about the world, not a lock with which to shut away our own possibilities.